A Battle for Land in Honduras • Susan Meiselas • Magnum Photos

Magnum Pro

Editorial Cultural Commercial Search Image Archive

Welcome to the New Magnum Photos Site

Explore the award-winning storytelling work of Magnum photographers here, or head to Magnum Pro to search and license photos from Magnum’s acclaimed image archive.

CONTINUE TO NEW SITE
SEARCH PHOTO ARCHIVE IN MAGNUM PRO
Social Issues

A Battle for Land in Honduras

More than two centuries after settling in Honduras, the Garifuna people are still fighting for a place to raise their families

Susan Meiselas

Susan Meiselas El Mirador, with the UK Marella cruise ship in bay and statue of Christopher Columbus pointing to where he first landed in Central America. Trujillo. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos (...)

This article, by Sarah Kinosian, was originally published under the title The Last Resort alongside Susan Meiselas’ photographs in Pacific Standard Magazine, August 2018. This report was a part of Pacific Standard‘s A Journey Through Contested Lands photo issue, produced in conjunction with Magnum Photographers and made possible thanks to support from the Pulitzer Center.

The first cruise ship landed in Trujillo, Honduras, on October 15th, 2014—a 2,376-passenger Norwegian Cruise Line vessel with more than 1,000 crew members. It was the first realization of a grand tourism plan hatched by Canadian “Porn King” Randy Jorgensen, who had made his fortune operating adult video stores before expanding into real-estate investments.

Since arriving in Trujillo in 1991, Jorgensen has bought more than 1,500 acres, including land that once belonged to the Garifuna, descendants of escaped African slaves and indigenous Caribbean tribes who—after a failed uprising on St. Vincent against the British in 1797—were forced to resettle in Honduras. Once the inhabitants of expansive strips of untouched greenery, virgin beaches, and ports right on the Caribbean Sea, the Garifuna have lost thousands of acres to greed, corruption, foreign business interests, and tourism.

Susan Meiselas British tourists on Banana Coast tour in town central square. Trujillo. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

"Jorgensen’s goal, in part, is to make Trujillo the go-to escape for thousands of foreign retirees, and his vision has attracted other foreign investors"

-
Susan Meiselas Honduran tourists visit Fort Santa Barbara. Trujillo. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

Jorgensen’s goal, in part, is to make Trujillo the go-to escape for thousands of foreign retirees, and his vision has attracted other foreign investors to Trujillo Bay. The Garifuna contend local mayors and community leaders have sold their land illegally and say they have been largely excluded from the resulting tourism profits.

While Honduras has ratified several international declarations and conventions protecting the land rights of indigenous groups, the government has offered little support, arguing in international hearings that the Garifuna are immigrants, and therefore have no right to the land. Meanwhile, President Juan Orlando Hernandez, looking to reshape the country’s notorious reputation for violence with increased investment in development and resource extraction, has made it easier for outsiders to acquire property.

The Garifuna culture is inextricably tied to the land. Each morning men walk down to the beach to fish, while women cook spreads of coconut bread, fish stew, and yucca. Theirs is a matrilineal society: Women pass on the knowledge, myths, and memories of the Garifuna people to the next generation. With their culture at stake, they are leading a movement to reclaim their ancestral lands through occupation. They are building homes and planting crops on territory they say is rightfully theirs. With each new effort, they beat drums to invoke their ancestors, who they believe will guide the fight to preserve their land.

Susan Meiselas Local beach where fisherman launch daily. Rio Esteban. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

"[The Garifuna] are leading a movement to reclaim their ancestral lands through occupation. They are building homes and planting crops on territory they say is rightfully theirs."

-
Susan Meiselas Resettlement community 'Wamua' of women. Guadalupe. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos
Susan Meiselas Building home at Recuperated land, Wani Lee. Santa Fe. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

Remittances are crucial to the Garifuna. With little opportunity for employment, many Garifuna, mostly men, migrate to the United States. This often leaves Garifuna women like Paulina, 57, and Emiliana, 67, to wake up at 5 a.m. to harvest crops of yucca, banana, and coconut, the core ingredients of Garifuna cooking.

Now some Garifuna men are returning to find the land where they planned to raise their children sold off. “I came back for a visit, but when I saw what was starting to happen I wanted to come back quickly because if I didn’t there wasn’t going to be anything left for us. I knew I had to come back and fight,” says Nerlin “Rocky” Noel. “We are losing our culture, and the land is an important part of that. It’s who we are, and it’s how we self-sustain.”

 

Susan Meiselas Paulina, 57, harvesting and replanting yucca. Guadalupe. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

"Canadian investors who reportedly had plans to build a mall on the land threatened the men regularly. Two years ago, the police torched the provisional homes the brothers had built. "

-
Susan Meiselas Julio Lino, showing wound from shooting during a recovery of land in 2011. Trujillo. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

Three years ago, Rocky and his brother Nilfor, who both lived in New York for nearly 20 years, established a settlement on a plot of land in the town of Santa Fe, which they named Wani Lee. Canadian investors who reportedly had plans to build a mall on the land threatened the men regularly. Two years ago, the police torched the provisional homes the brothers had built. In recent months, they’ve begun to rebuild.

“We used to play on this land as kids. Now we can’t even step foot on it without a security guard kicking us off,” Rocky says, looking out over a beachfront lot across the street from Wani Lee, which was allegedly sold illegally. “My kids will never know what it’s like to play on this land, so I’ve got to give them something.”

Susan Meiselas Recuperated land, with daughter Mirsa of leader Nerlin Noel. Santa Fe. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos
Susan Meiselas Geohary, 23, recuperation of beach property. Santa Fe. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

"We used to play on this land as kids. Now we can’t even step foot on it without a security guard kicking us off"

-
Susan Meiselas Elsa, wife of leader of Wani Lee recuperated land, Nerlin Noel in their new home. Santa Fe. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

Elsa, Rocky’s partner, is the only woman living on the Wani Lee territory. All others left after the clash with police, afraid to return. “There’s no longer any land left in Santa Fe to live,” she says. “We need this and it’s ours. I hope to build my life on this land with my children.”

The Wamua settlement in Guadalupe is the site of the most hotly contested land dispute in Trujillo Bay. Many Garifuna say the land at Wamua was illegally sold by a member of the community to Patrick Forseth, the part-owner and general manager of Carivida, a multinational tourism and real-estate company. Forseth, who lives in Honduras, contends that the government’s approval of the title transfer gives him legal claim to the land.

In 2016, Medalime David and several other Garifuna began sleeping on the land to prevent Carivida from developing there. David was gathering wood to cook dinner one afternoon in November when police stormed the property and arrested her for land usurpation.

Susan Meiselas Recuperated land, Wani Lee. Santa Fe. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

"Any conflict, we’ll be there with our drums and maracas, because guns we don’t have—just our culture, our hearts, and our ancestral instruments"

-

A group of Garifuna still maintains a near-continuous presence in provisional housing on the Wamua land, with plans to build around 40 more permanent homes. Carivida has filed charges against several of their leaders, including David, who faces defamation and usurpation lawsuits, and is barred from leaving the country or visiting the site. “I feel like a prisoner,” she says.

But she is undeterred. “Any conflict, we’ll be there with our drums and maracas, because guns we don’t have—just our culture, our hearts, and our ancestral instruments.”

 

Susan Meiselas Trujillo. Honduras. 2018. © Susan Meiselas/Magnum Photos with support from the Pulitzer Center © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos
This project was made possible thanks to support from the Pulitzer Center.
This article appeared in Pacific Standard’s 2018 Photo Issue, Contested Lands, made in collaboration with Magnum Photos.