Arts & Culture

Susan Meiselas: Carnival Strippers Revisited

As the third edition of Susan Meiselas' Carnival Strippers is released, and a related show opens at the Magnum Gallery in Paris, we share an extract from an essay by Abigail Soloman-Godeau that examines the project in the context of Meiselas' entire career.

Susan Meiselas

Susan Meiselas Left: Shortie Takes over the Bally, Barton, Vermont, 1974. Right: Contact frame of Shortie on the Bally, Barton, Vermont, 1974. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

Between 1972-76, Susan Meiselas followed carnival strippers who performed in country fairs across the northeast of the USA. Her meticulous documentation of their working lives explored themes of intimacy, vulnerability, nomadism, gender politics and sexuality. The third edition of her book, published by Steidl, will be released this March. Carnival Strippers Revisited features never-before-seen color photographs, contact sheets, handwritten field notes, transcriptions of audio recordings, and more.  

Click here to purchase a signed copy from Magnum before the public release.

To coincide with the book launch, a new exhibition will open at the Magnum Gallery in Paris on February 17. Carnival Strippers: Revisited will present, for the first time, Meiselas’ color photographs taken in the 1970s. To learn more about the show and visiting hours, click here

Below we share an extract from an essay in the new Steidl third edition by art historian, critic, and curator Abigail Soloman-Godeau, titled Reading Carnival Strippers in 2021.

Susan Meiselas The Star Tease, Tunbridge, Vermont. 1975. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

In the early 1970s, the existence of extravagant strip shows in nightclubs, music halls, and theaters, and the careers of celebrity strippers such as Gypsy Rose Lee were still extant. Such performers were considered icons of glamour, erotic allure, and financial success. Most of these star strippers too had working-class origins. Indeed, interviews given by celebrity performers speak of small-town or impoverished histories similar to those of Meiselas’s subjects. But the tawdry trappings of Meiselas’s girl shows—even then, and for many reasons, in the process of decline—were as far from the extravagant performances of a Gypsy Rose Lee as they were from the moon. 

By virtue of the date of its production, its material fabrication—black-and-white analog photography, a hand-held Leica—and its depiction of a now-vanished milieu, Carnival Strippers has become a historical document. This means that its diverse components, including photographs, sound recordings, written transcriptions, and correspondence between Meiselas and her subjects, have come together (and now more or less live together) as a particular archive. As an archive—and as Meiselas emphasized in the eponymous title of her 2008 exhibition and catalog—the photographer and her subjects are inescapably embedded In History. (1) These narratives are as much produced by the individuals represented through their own testimony as by the formal operations of the visual documentation itself. “The photos,” Meiselas writes in another context, “are immediate encounters that last only a moment. Later, these face-to-face encounters can serve as the basis for more elaborate narratives that go beyond the story of a person to that of a culture or a country.”(2) These “more elaborate narratives” are therefore threefold. Emanating from the individual or the event, there are the contents of her archival documentation; second, there are her supplemental materials generated by sound recordings and interviews, and third, her follow-up activities, whether of individuals or events that recontextualize what she has previously documented. (This is especially evident in her Reframing History project, for which she returned to the scene of the photographs she first made in the 1978 Sandinista revolution that then became her landmark book Nicaragua.) (3) 

Susan Meiselas Left: Tent Entrance for Star and Garter, Essex Junction, Vermont, 1974. Right: Contact frame with The Managers, Star and Garter, Essex Junction, Vermont, 1974. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

From a general perspective, this embeddedness in history is obviously the condition of photography in general. This is only to say that all extant photographs may be situated within a spectrum somewhere between the microcosmic—the material remains of individual lives, the existing traces of their lifeworld—and the macrocosmic—the time, place, culture, and all the other impersonal circumstances and determinations that have formed and shaped the individual subject and her or his lived circumstances. In effect, all photographs are a kind of time capsule whose significance may be teased out or lost altogether, but whose reading (or misreading) is inevitably filtered through contemporary eyes. 

Most photographers, then or now, amass archives of one sort or another. Typically, and often posthumously, these concern the work and/ or life of the photographer herself. But Meiselas’s archival approach, from its inception in Carnival Strippers on, has expanded in breadth and depth, incorporating what is absent from photography as such, namely, the context that helps explain the situation that is the subject of representation. By the time she inaugurated the projects that became Encounters with the Dani and the ongoing undertaking Kurdistan: In the Shadow of History, she dispensed with most of her own photographs other than those joined with other photographers accompanying the latter book’s timeline.(4) After 2003, her own photographs were employed as counterpoints to those of others such as in Cova de Moura (2004) and A Room of Their Own, a series devoted to battered women and their shelter.(5) 

Susan Meiselas Contact frames of Through the Dressing Room, Barton, Vermont, 1974. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

It is not the easiest thing to distinguish between what are called photographic documentary practices and those considered to fall under the category of photo reportage. But generally speaking, the former category is more flexible, enabling ever more complex, more expansive, innovative, and hybridized forms. While the latter category presumes a paid (or salaried) labor, often generated by others and a priori destined for print or other media, Carnival Strippers as an independent project, and given some of its more fraught subject matter, had its own particular history. It was first exhibited in a small museum in Brockton, Massachusetts, in 1974 and again in 1975 with live sound at the artists’ space CEPA in Buffalo, New York. Its permanent book form only appeared in 1976 in American and French editions. From this early work, Meiselas’s projects have evolved increasingly towards a transactional and participative mode that has developed into an archivally, and often collectively conceived form of representation. 

Susan Meiselas Work print of Lena Waiting for the Crowd, Barton, Vermont, 1974. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

"Meiselas’s projects have evolved increasingly towards a transactional and participative mode that has developed into an archivally, and often collectively conceived form of representation. "

-
Susan Meiselas Printer’s proof of Mitzi, Tunbridge, Vermont, 1974. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos
Susan Meiselas Contact sheet with Mitzi, Tunbridge, Vermont, 1974. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos
Susan Meiselas Contact sheet with Lena Waiting for the Crowd and Tami and Shortie Sharing Smoke, Barton, Vermont, 1974. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos
Susan Meiselas Work print of Lena Waiting for the Crowd, Barton, Vermont, 1974. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos
Susan Meiselas Left: Work print of Shortie at Work, South Carolina, 1973. Right: Excerpt of audio exchange between Shortie and men, date unknown. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos
Susan Meiselas Left: Susan Meiselas, field notebook, 1973–75. Right: Stack of printer’s proofs with Lena on the Bally, Barton, Vermont, 1974. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos
Susan Meiselas Susan Meiselas, drawing of the girl show, 1973. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos
Susan Meiselas Susan Meiselas, field notebook, 1973–75. © Susan Meiselas | Magnum Photos

References:

1.  Susan Meiselas, In History (New York: International Center of Photography; Göttingen: Steidl, 2008).
2. Susan Meiselas, En première ligne (Paris: Éditions Xavier Barral, 2018), 16. My translation. “Les photos sont desrencontres immédiates qui ne durent qu’un instant. Par la suite, ces faces-à-faces peuvent servir de supports à des récits plus élaborés qui dépassent l’histoire d’une personne pour s’ouvrir à celle d’une culture ou d’un pays.”
3. Susan Meiselas, Nicaragua: June 1978–July 1979 (New York: Pantheon Books, 1981).
4. Kurdistan: In the Shadow of History (New York: Random House, 1997) and Encounters with the Dani: Stories from the Baliem Valley (New York: International Center of Photography; Göttingen: Steidl, 2003).
5. Susan Meiselas, A Room of Their Own (West Bromwich: Multistory, 2017).

Stay in touch
Stay up to date every Thursday with Magnum photographers’ activities, new work, stories published on the Magnum website, and the latest offerings from our shop.
Be the first to know about recent Magnum Shop drops. From new books and limited editions, to special offers, you can find it all on the weekly Magnum Shop newsletter.
Get fortnightly tips and advice articles, find out about the latest workshops, free online events and on-demand courses.
Learn about online and offline exhibitions, photography fairs, gallery events, plus fine print news and activities, on a monthly basis.
Know when our quarterly 7-day square print sale is coming.
Monthly updates on the latest assignments, photographer projects and collaborations with brands.