Bearing Witness: A Farewell to Cambodia • John Vink • Magnum Photos

Magnum Pro

Editorial Cultural Commercial Search Image Archive

Welcome to the New Magnum Photos Site

Explore the award-winning storytelling work of Magnum photographers here, or head to Magnum Pro to search and license photos from Magnum’s acclaimed image archive.

CONTINUE TO NEW SITE
SEARCH PHOTO ARCHIVE IN MAGNUM PRO
Politics

Bearing Witness: A Farewell to Cambodia

John Vink gives a personal reflection on 16 years of social and political upheaval as he bids Cambodia goodbye

John Vink

John Vink Members of the Boeung Kak Lake community, entangled in a land issue since 2007, try to push past a Police blockade preventing them from demonstrating in front of Prime Minister Hun Sen's house on S (...)

It started with me scrambling to replace a colleague who had to forsake a rare visa to Cambodia in 1989, and it ended with a stay of 16 years and a few months, time enough to see some profound changes in a country that was still reeling from the radical structural and mental devastation the brutal Khmer Rouge regime had left behind.

The pace of reconstruction and development between 2000 and 2016 would be remarkable, and I witnessed first-hand the mechanisms of such a fast development. Mistakes made over the course of half a century in the West in order to develop and prosper were made in a 10-year period in Cambodia. Establishing a functioning democracy would take much more than the $1.6 USD billion spent by the UN during the time of the United Nations Transitional Authority in Cambodia in 1991. If it indeed managed to organize elections in 1993, it later goofed heavily under pressure from Hun Sen, head of the Cambodian People’s Party, by naming two Prime Ministers: Prince Norodom Ranariddh’s FUNCINPEC had won more votes than the CPP (45.5% to 38.2%), but suddenly Hun Sen was sharing power with him. The seeds were sown for mayhem. All this was exactly why I decided to stay so long: I had a hunch it would be worthwhile to stay and work in-depth.

John Vink Former Boeung Kak lake residents, supported by buddhist monks, demonstrate in front of the municipality building. Phnom Penh, Cambodia. 23rd December, 2013. © John Vink | Magnum Photos
John Vink Yorm Bopha, land rights activist and Amnesty International Prisoner of Conscience, leaving the Appeals Court after the first day of her trial. Phnom Penh, Cambodia. 5th June, 2013. © John Vink | Magnum Photos
John Vink Sam Rainsy, head of the opposition CNRP leads a demonstration for the 5th consecutive day in the streets of Phnom Penh to request that Prime Minister Hun Sen abandon power after 28 years, following (...)

Little did I know that the Prime Minister I photographed in 1989 during the Day of Hatred ceremony at the killing fields of Choeung Ek would still be at the helm of the country in 2016. On that blazing hot day at the foot of the memorial stupa, containing the bones of those killed at the S21 Khmer Rouge interrogation center, Mr. Hun Sen, like all the other officials – the core of the network he would rely on to stay in power for the next decades – was modestly dressed with dark trousers and a white shirt wrapping his still slim body when distributing rice to the monks. His frog-like glasses only partially concealed the scar on his left eyebrow and the fixed stare of his glass eye, a reminder of his years spent as a Khmer Rouge soldier before defecting and, with the help of neighboring Vietnam, pushing back his former comrades to a few pockets of safe havens at the borders while taking the reins of power in his hands.

After a coup in 1997; a series of elections tainted with irregularities; the use of rhetoric instilling fear; a few assassinations of union leaders or political opponents; and with the implementation, by a judiciary system that has difficulty in demonstrating any kind of independence from the executive, of a number of laws sufficiently vague to send critics to jail for defamation or other trivialities, Samdech Akeak Moha Sena Padey Techo Hun Sen (Lord Prime Minister, Supreme Military Commander Hun Sen) still holds a strong grip on power today.

John Vink A large police force stops a demonstration by SL Garment Processing (Cambodia) Ltd. entangled in a long conflict with its directors. The factory specializes in various wet and dry processes for den (...)

"Cambodia is ranked 150 out of 168 countries for 2015 on a corruption perception index by Transparency International"

-
John Vink A protester getting a tiger balsam rub while several communities, which suffered land issues gather in front of the City Hall to seek a final resolution to the lingering conflicts. Phnom Penh, Camb (...)
John Vink Ladies of honour waiting for HRH Princess Sisowath Pongsanmony to arrive at the commemoration ceremony for the loss of Kampuchea Krom to Vietnam in 1949, at the Samaki Reangsey pagoda. Cambodia, Ph (...)
John Vink Buddhist monks on the afternoon of the 4th day of the anti-Vietnamese demonstration organised by the Khmer Kampuchea Krom Association to protest the annexation of Kampuchea Krom by Vietnam in 1949. (...)
John Vink The fifth and last day of a 'Peace March' which took groups of citizens and monks along the national highways towards Phnom Penh to promote human rights ahead of International Human Rights Day on D (...)

According to a recently released report by Global Witness, which relied on information readily available on the Ministry of Commerce website, ‘Lord Prime Minister, Supreme Military Commander Hun Sen’ has amassed millions of dollars through the network of his extended family. This does not come as a big surprise to me; Cambodia is ranked 150 out of 168 countries for 2015 on a corruption perception index by Transparency International.

The first time since 1997 that Mr. Hun Sen’s autocratic reign came under threat was with the 2013 elections. The opposition CNRP, headed by Sam Rainsy and Kem Sokha, won 44,46% of the votes against 48,33% for the CPP. The results were challenged by the opposition, which accused the ruling party of having organized frauds, and a months-long arm wrestle started, with the CNRP refusing to occupy the 55 seats (out of 123) it was entitled to. For days on end demonstrations and sit-ins were staged by the opposition, garment factory workers went on strike demanding better pay and conditions, and pressure from the street gained ground.

John Vink Members of the Borei Keila community, embroiled in a land conflict since 2007, pray in front of a bowl containing soil from the area they were evicted from before bringing it to the Preah Ang Dongk (...)
John Vink Monks and citizens, on a five day 'Peace March' to promote human rights, take a rest after lunch. The event takes several groups along national highways in the country, which converge on Phnom Penh (...)

The momentum for change came to a brutal end in early January. The army fired on striking workers, killing several demonstrators. ‘Freedom Park’, the location for a quasi-permanent public forum organized by the opposition, was forcefully evacuated and sealed off. An iron fist hammered down any public dissent and the biased judicial system used the law to imprison members of the opposition, human rights workers, parliamentarians, and eco-activists. Sam Rainsy was forced to go on self-imposed exile, and Kem Sokha was forced to seek refuge at the CNRP headquarters for the last couple of months out of fear of being arrested for an alleged infidelity. The ‘Culture of Dialogue’, negotiated between the two main parties to eventually end the stalemate after the elections, turned into a memory from a distant past.

John Vink Demonstrators confront municipal guards after they ripped off a banner, attached by the protesters, to the barbed wire fence during the demonstration staged by the opposition CNRP demanding access (...)
John Vink A protester showing fake US dollar bills in front of a police blockade near the European Union office, during a demonstration by various civil society groups against a controversial refugee deal be (...)
John Vink On the occasion of First Lady Michelle Obama visiting Siem Reap in the coming days, representatives from various communities in Phnom Penh, together with their children, gather in front of the U.S. (...)
John Vink A striking worker arrested and beaten up by armed forces during a brutal crackdown at Veng Sreng road. Phnom Penh, Cambodia. 3rd January, 2014. © John Vink | Magnum Photos

"It is only recently, only a few days before the assassination on July 10th of Kem Ley, an outspoken political analyst, critical of both sides, that some of my foreign colleagues and I started to feel that we were becoming a potential target for the authorities"

-
John Vink Municipal Guards trying to stop protesters during a demonstration near the Vietnamese Embassy of about 200 members from the Khmer Youth Movement, joined by other civil society groups, over what the (...)
John Vink Stones thrown by striking workers who pulled up barricades on Veng Sreng road before being brutally dispersed by armed forces, resulting in at least three dead, one injured and 3 confirmed arrests (...)

Strangely enough, during the 18 months after the 2013 elections, during which I covered more than 200 demonstrations, my colleagues and I were never prevented from working, from documenting the turmoil, the brutality, the deception, the fear, the anger, the hopes. It is only recently, only a few days before the assassination on July 10th of Kem Ley, an outspoken political analyst, critical of both sides, that some of my foreign colleagues and I started to feel that we were becoming a potential target for the authorities.

The thousands of people who followed the funeral procession of Kem Ley two weeks after his assassination clearly show that this regime, based on corruption and repression, overseen by ruthlessly brutal thugs or by biased courts in the name of law, on fear and on greed, does not resonate favorably, to say the least, with a very large proportion of the population. Cambodia is definitely reaching a crossroads.

John Vink Sim Sovandy, a buddhist monk close to the opposition, together with other monks and family members, perform a ceremony for Kem Ley in the shop where he was assassinated. Outside, an angry crowd of (...)

I was asked to add some personal reflections on my years in Cambodia, now that I am leaving. It’s not something I feel really comfortable with because I still believe that photojournalism is about the message, not the messenger. However, I can say this: if Belgium gave me life, Cambodia made me understand it better because of its incredible generosity to this photographer. It may have taught me about greed and arrogance but it mainly taught me about resilience, about the power of resistance, about courage. I cannot believe that all those who stood up will not soon be rewarded with a life which will be more just and peaceful to them.

Hearths of Resistance, an ebook for the iPad and Mac is available on iTunes here. Many of the pictures from Hearths of Resistance will be exhibited in Berlin from Sep. 15th until Oct. 16 at the Fotofabrik Bln Bxl gallery.

John Vink The footsteps of Tep Vanny, a Boeung Kak Lake representative, chasing the fire trucks after members of her community had been dispersed by water canons when demonstrating in front of the Municipali (...)
John Vink A monk supporting the workers at Yakjin factory. They were dispersed in the morning by members of Unit 911 from the RCAF, which is stationed nearby, resulting in ten injured. Voan Pov, the Union Le (...)